Products in the “Penny Candy” Category
Anise Squares
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding 
Atomic Fireballs
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Banana Splits
Banana Splits are chewy cubes of banana flavored candy.
Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Bazooka Bubble Gum
Bazooka Bubble Gum… the classic bubble gum with a Bazooka Joe comic inside the wrapper.
Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Black Jack Taffy
Today it is called Black Taffy but it was originally called Black Jack Taffy and sometimes Black Jacks. It is a salt-water sized taffy with a swirl of licorice in the center.
Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Butterscotch Disks
Butterscotch Disks are individually wrapped butterscotch hard candies.
Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Caramel Creams (Bull’s Eyes)
Caramel Creams are sometimes called "Bulls Eyes" because of their look, caramel around the outside and a vanilla cream in the middle.
25 cents each/Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Caramel Cubes
Individually wrapped cubes of caramel.
Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Chocolate Gold Coins
Chocolate Gold Coins are solid milk chocolate wrapped in gold foil with a look similar to US coins. They are are little larger than the actual coins.
Ten pieces per order.
WARM WEATHER WARNING! This item can melt in transit. Order at your own risk during summer months or if you live in a warm climate. No Store Credit offered for melted candy!
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Dubble Bubble Gum
Dubble Bubble short twist wrap. This is not the 1928 flavor but what the Dubble Bubble folks call the "original" bubble gum flavor.
Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Honeycomb Peanuts
Honeycombed Peanuts are individually wrapped, peanut shaped hard candies with a soft center made with real peanut butter.
Sold 10 to an order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Ice Cube Chocolates
Ice Cubes... bite-size chocolate candy with a really smooth icy taste and they look like a... well, ice cube.
Sold 10 to an order.
WARM WEATHER WARNING! This item can melt in transit. Order at your own risk during summer months or if you live in a warm climate. No Store Credit offered for melted candy!
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Jawbreakers
Individually wrapped jawbreakers that are about 3/4 inch in diameter. They are available in assorted colors.
Sold 10 to an order, assorted.
Made in the USA!
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Long Boys – Chocolate
Chocolate Long Boys are chewy chocolate sticks that are 3 inches long.
Sold 10 to an order.
Made in the USA!
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Mary Janes
Mary Janes are bite-sized peanut butter and molasses candies originally made in 1914.
Made in the USA!
Theater Box 3.5 oz
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Mint Juleps
Mint Julep are chewy cubes of mint-flavored taffy.
Made in the USA!
Sold 10 to an order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Neapolitan Coconut Sundaes
Brach's Neapolitan Coconut Sundaes are candies that look like Neapolitan Ice Cream. Each bite size piece has the Chocolate, Vanilla, and Strawberry flavors are made with real coconut. If you like coconut, you will love these!
Made in the USA!
Sold 10 to an order.
Currently unavailable as the manufacturer has discontinued this candy. :(
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Peanut Butter Bars
They're crunchy, they're crispy, they're almost flaky and they're truly addictive. Atkinson's Peanut Butter Bars are perfect if you love peanut butter in a portable snack.
Made in the USA!
Sold 10 to an order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Pixy Stix
Pixy Stix are candy powder filled straws in 4 flavors which are blue raspberry, cherry, grape and orange.
Sold 10 to an order, assorted flavors.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Root Beer Barrels
Individually wrapped I.B.C. root beer flavored hard candy in the shape of a barrel.
Sold 10 to an order.
Made in the USA!
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Salt Water Taffy
In 1910 Sweet Candy Company introduced its world-famous, gourmet taffy. Sweet's Taffy is markedly different from the version of salt water taffy known along the Eastern shore. Sweet's Salt Water Taffy is whipped, not pulled, allowing for a flavorful, less sticky, softer piece of taffy.
Sold 10 to an order, assorted flavors.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Soda Poppers
Brach's Soda Poppers are soft-centered, hard candies with the taste of popular sodas (or pop as we say in Ohio). There are 4 flavors: A&W Root Beer, Dr. Pepper, Orange Crush and 7 Up. The pieces are an inch long and 1/2 inch in diameter.
Sold 10 to an order, assorted flavors.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Soft Peppermint Balls
Bobs Sweet Stripes Mint Balls are soft peppermint balls that are roughly 3/4 inch in diameter.
Ten pieces per order.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied on very small orders to cover the cost of postage. You will be notified before your order is processed if this is the case. Your best deal is to order several items at once so that the cumulative charges will be adequate to cover the postage. Thank you for understanding
Sour Fruit Balls
Sour Fruit Balls are hard candy balls in assorted flavors which are cherry, lemon, grape, lime and orange.
Sold 10 to an order, assortment of flavors.
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Squirrel Nut Zippers
Squirrel Nut Zippers are chewy peanut caramels with emphasis on the "chewy." Make sure those baby-boomer teeth are in good shape. Some of you will remember these as Squirrel Nut Chews. They are the same candy but with a different name.
Sold 10 to an order.
Made in the USA!
More Details
Shipping Charges are calculated per piece; however, we clearly cannot ship one piece of candy for pennies, so a minimum charge will be applied to cover the cost of postage. We will refund any overage when you order multiple items.
Updating...